|
Post by Aurelia on Jan 7, 2021 20:08:27 GMT -5
The crescent was a nod to the Hungarian origins of the Hussar, many of whom were Muslim. (Actually, I like the Goddess of the Hunt interpretation better - the hunting horn became the almost universal symbol of light infantry everywhere). The Diana connection is just what the Canadian Queen's York Rangers (who trace back to Robert Roger's Rangers) gave as an explanation. They just kinda said "Cresent moon for the goddess Diana", but I'm guessing it was Diana's attributes... Or perhaps Queen Charlotte had some association with Diana?
|
|
|
Post by andrew on Jan 8, 2021 8:59:16 GMT -5
The crescent was a nod to the Hungarian origins of the Hussar, many of whom were Muslim. (Actually, I like the Goddess of the Hunt interpretation better - the hunting horn became the almost universal symbol of light infantry everywhere). The Diana connection is just what the Canadian Queen's York Rangers (who trace back to Robert Roger's Rangers) gave as an explanation. They just kinda said "Cresent moon for the goddess Diana", but I'm guessing it was Diana's attributes... Or perhaps Queen Charlotte had some association with Diana? I used to share a parade square with the QYR. I never saw that symbol though; I suppose it has long fallen out of use. But yes, you're quite right. The regimental association gives exactly the explanation you do: www.qyrang.ca/blog/2016/4/17/warriors-of-the-crescent-moon
|
|
|
Post by Windischer on Jan 8, 2021 13:01:52 GMT -5
Indeed. I find green is always an interesting colour back in that period and the infantry hat reminds me a bit of what the Austrians wore back then. I wasn't however able to find any info on their halfmoon badge. Any idea what's the origin and meaning of that? Seems like the cresent moon is used in reference to Artemis/Diana... I.e. the goddess of the hunt, with a silent predatory bird as her companion. It might seem like a stretch, but back then there was a fixation on ancient Greco-Roman ideas, myths, symbolism, etc, so this would have been a much more viable option to pick off the top of their head than it is for us. The Queen's Rangers, with this symbol of intelligence and predatory acumen seems like a good fit. I may not have mentioned it, but they were basically like the 'special ops' of the British... they could live off the land and were schooled in all manner of guerilla / recon / "Dirty Tricks" type skills. They were basically schooled in badassery... 😄 Though these uniforms were only brought into use after 1780... Makes enough sense to me. Cresents aren't that common of a symbol in Europe. Some were used in heraldry, but that's it. I guess because of its strong association with islam, which is what they reminded me of instantly. Now, andrew is joking about muslim hussars, but there could possibly still be a connection to islam, if the founders of the unit were freemasons. High levels of freemasonry have some connection to islamic symbolism. Think of the shriners. Given how this was in the US, where the elites often were members of similar organisations, would it be that far fetched?
|
|
|
Post by andrew on Jan 8, 2021 15:20:54 GMT -5
Seems like the cresent moon is used in reference to Artemis/Diana... I.e. the goddess of the hunt, with a silent predatory bird as her companion. It might seem like a stretch, but back then there was a fixation on ancient Greco-Roman ideas, myths, symbolism, etc, so this would have been a much more viable option to pick off the top of their head than it is for us. The Queen's Rangers, with this symbol of intelligence and predatory acumen seems like a good fit. I may not have mentioned it, but they were basically like the 'special ops' of the British... they could live off the land and were schooled in all manner of guerilla / recon / "Dirty Tricks" type skills. They were basically schooled in badassery... 😄 Though these uniforms were only brought into use after 1780... Makes enough sense to me. Cresents aren't that common of a symbol in Europe. Some were used in heraldry, but that's it. I guess because of its strong association with islam, which is what they reminded me of instantly. Now, andrew is joking about muslim hussars, but there could possibly still be a connection to islam, if the founders of the unit were freemasons. High levels of freemasonry have some connection to islamic symbolism. Think of the shriners. Given how this was in the US, where the elites often were members of similar organisations, would it be that far fetched? No, I actually read it on a website, but didn't have to the basic common sense to fact-check it on the QYR's own websites. I looked at the picture, saw what I thought was a hussar, and looked no further. My bad. Regarding Hussars generally, the Hussar (of the light cavalry variety) is most definitely a Hungarian creation, hailing primarily from Serbia. The name itself is Hungarian. But now I'm not sure if Serbia has (or had) a high muslim population or not. I made an assumption there. Another bad. I've also read that the white over red pennon of lancer units is also a nod to their ancestry, in that case Poland, being the Polish national colours. But I read that long before the advent of the internet and have never tried to verify it. The adoption of foreign military uniforms and types was pretty common right up to the end of the 19th century. Look at the American Zouaves.
|
|
|
Post by Aurelia on Jan 9, 2021 9:05:20 GMT -5
Makes enough sense to me. Cresents aren't that common of a symbol in Europe. Some were used in heraldry, but that's it. I guess because of its strong association with islam, which is what they reminded me of instantly. Now, andrew is joking about muslim hussars, but there could possibly still be a connection to islam, if the founders of the unit were freemasons. High levels of freemasonry have some connection to islamic symbolism. Think of the shriners. Given how this was in the US, where the elites often were members of similar organisations, would it be that far fetched? Huh! The Freemasonry connection is an interesting thought...
|
|
|
Post by Aurelia on Jan 9, 2021 9:39:13 GMT -5
No, I actually read it on a website, but didn't have to the basic common sense to fact-check it on the QYR's own websites. I looked at the picture, saw what I thought was a hussar, and looked no further. My bad. Regarding Hussars generally, the Hussar (of the light cavalry variety) is most definitely a Hungarian creation, hailing primarily from Serbia. The name itself is Hungarian. But now I'm not sure if Serbia has (or had) a high muslim population or not. I made an assumption there. Another bad. I've also read that the white over red pennon of lancer units is also a nod to their ancestry, in that case Poland, being the Polish national colours. But I read that long before the advent of the internet and have never tried to verify it. The adoption of foreign military uniforms and types was pretty common right up to the end of the 19th century. Look at the American Zouaves. I just have had a bit of a Queen's Rangers obsession for a while. I would want to go join and learn to be a killer, survivalist badass of the 1700's - though I probably wouldn't be allowed. 😒 American Zouaves is another topic I'm always talking to Windischer about. Why did a bunch of random guys in the 1800's decide to dress that way and fight? Maybe we need a thread about uniforms.
|
|
|
Post by andrew on Jan 9, 2021 16:16:28 GMT -5
I just have had a bit of a Queen's Rangers obsession for a while. I would want to go join and learn to be a killer, survivalist badass of the 1700's - though I probably wouldn't be allowed. 😒 I'm still angry about their portrayal in "Turn" - particularly the character assassination of Simcoe. The man did so many good things he has a holiday named for him here!
|
|
|
Post by Windischer on Jan 10, 2021 13:23:04 GMT -5
Makes enough sense to me. Cresents aren't that common of a symbol in Europe. Some were used in heraldry, but that's it. I guess because of its strong association with islam, which is what they reminded me of instantly. Now, andrew is joking about muslim hussars, but there could possibly still be a connection to islam, if the founders of the unit were freemasons. High levels of freemasonry have some connection to islamic symbolism. Think of the shriners. Given how this was in the US, where the elites often were members of similar organisations, would it be that far fetched? No, I actually read it on a website, but didn't have to the basic common sense to fact-check it on the QYR's own websites. I looked at the picture, saw what I thought was a hussar, and looked no further. My bad. Regarding Hussars generally, the Hussar (of the light cavalry variety) is most definitely a Hungarian creation, hailing primarily from Serbia. The name itself is Hungarian. But now I'm not sure if Serbia has (or had) a high muslim population or not. I made an assumption there. Another bad. I've also read that the white over red pennon of lancer units is also a nod to their ancestry, in that case Poland, being the Polish national colours. But I read that long before the advent of the internet and have never tried to verify it. The adoption of foreign military uniforms and types was pretty common right up to the end of the 19th century. Look at the American Zouaves. Which is interesting again, because hussars afaik weren't a common thing in the British armed forces until later, in the Napoleonic period, when several Light Dragoons regiments were renamed to Hussar regiments. We see a similar thing happening after Waterloo, when some Light Dragoons regiments get transformed into Lancer units. Lancers were originally more of a Eastern European thing. Poles (Uhlans) and Russians (Cossacks) used the lance quite a bit. As Poland got partitioned, the tree conquering powers adopted Uhlan units. Napoleon made the Duchy of Warszaw his ally and modelled several units after the Polish Uhlans. The famous "Red Lancers" were a mostly Dutch unit, but their uniform was mimicing the Polish one, especially the square top shako, inspired by a Polish hat called "czapka rogatywka". Because Lancers were used in Napoleon's army with quite some cussess, his enemies (the British) started using them as well, again modeling the uniforms after the Polish style. Like you said, the light Hussars as we're most familiar with them were originally a mounted police formation in the Kingdom of Hungary. At first they comprised mostly of Serbs but that changed later on. As part of the lands ruled by the Habsburgs, it became an rule that Hussars were only recruited from lands of the Kingdom of Hungary (that includes Slovakia, Croatia, Vojvodina, Transylvania etc), while the "German" lands (today's Czechia, Austria, Slovenia and parts of Northern Italy) fielded Dragoons and Cuirassiers. So the ethnic makeup was one big mix. Serbia has a muslim population in Sandjak, on the border with Montenegro. They're called Bosniaks, the same as the muslims from Bosnia and Hercegovina. I don't know if the Albanians living on the Serbian side of the border with Kosovo are muslim or not. I assume there were more muslims in Serbia before its independance in the 19th century. Hungary probably recruited those Serbian Hussars from lands it controlled, which would be Vojvodina (no muslims there). Another point we overlooked is that islam was not tolerated in Austria back then. The 1781 Patent of Toleranation by Joseph II only granted religious freedom to Lutherans, Calvinists and Serbian Orthodox Christians and the 1782 Edict of Tolerance extended it to include Jews as well. Islam was not tolerated because of the constant wars with the Ottomans.
|
|
|
Post by Windischer on Jan 10, 2021 13:26:11 GMT -5
No, I actually read it on a website, but didn't have to the basic common sense to fact-check it on the QYR's own websites. I looked at the picture, saw what I thought was a hussar, and looked no further. My bad. Regarding Hussars generally, the Hussar (of the light cavalry variety) is most definitely a Hungarian creation, hailing primarily from Serbia. The name itself is Hungarian. But now I'm not sure if Serbia has (or had) a high muslim population or not. I made an assumption there. Another bad. I've also read that the white over red pennon of lancer units is also a nod to their ancestry, in that case Poland, being the Polish national colours. But I read that long before the advent of the internet and have never tried to verify it. The adoption of foreign military uniforms and types was pretty common right up to the end of the 19th century. Look at the American Zouaves. I just have had a bit of a Queen's Rangers obsession for a while. I would want to go join and learn to be a killer, survivalist badass of the 1700's - though I probably wouldn't be allowed. 😒 American Zouaves is another topic I'm always talking to Windischer about. Why did a bunch of random guys in the 1800's decide to dress that way and fight? Maybe we need a thread about uniforms. First off: yes, we definitely need a thread on uniforms. I think Americans created Zouave units because they modeled their army after the French. The two gentlemen in this video explain some of that obsession with everything French in this video:
|
|
|
Post by andrew on Jan 10, 2021 17:47:16 GMT -5
I wasn't able to find any Masonic connection to Rogers. Since he would have been paying out of pocket some or even all of the costs of outfitting the unit, we can assume he had some say in their dress. Remember Lord Cardigan!
|
|